Vegan Peanut Butter Cookies that taste like the traditional recipe? Yes please!
No one will know this peanut butter cookie recipe is vegan unless you tell them! Scroll down to learn all the tricks we used to create this delicious cookie that’s crisp on the outside, chewy inside and so nutty!
I love baking, but vegan baking is not really my forte. The truth is I totally understand the science and technique of traditional baking and vegan baking breaks all those rules. But sometimes I’m able to ignore my instincts screaming at me and create a vegan WINNER! Maybe it was my love of peanut butter or maybe all the research I did, but these vegan peanut butter cookies turned out awesome!
In the past I’ve used flax seeds as the binder for vegan baking recipes, but I’m not fond of the flavor or texture of a flax egg in cookies. Enter aquafaba! You know the bean water you normally pour down the drain after you open a can of chickpeas? It’s an amazing egg replacement!
But the other thing I did differently was use olive oil instead of a solid fat. It’s inspired by this vegan chocolate chip cookie recipe. I’ve never made them but I was really intrigued by the idea of using a liquid oil in cookies. Another interesting part of the recipe is that it calls for resting the dough. This isn’t a new concept. It’s often done with cookies with a high butter content because you don’t want the fat melting quickly in the oven, making flat cookies.
But beyond solidifying the liquid fat, resting the dough also improves the flavor and texture of the cookies. This is because of a process called hydration where the water and flour in a recipe chemically bond making stretchier, chewier baked goods. The best description I’ve found is this little article from Guy Crosby. It explains the science behind this phenomenon.
But who cares about science? You want your vegan peanut butter cookies to taste fantastic! Good news is these do. They are crisp on the outside and delightfully chewy inside. Plus the peanut butter flavor! Oh my it’s so pronounced! I made the unusual choice to use both peanut butter and peanut powder in this recipe because of the liquid fat. Instead of adding more flour into the recipe, I opted for peanut powder so the signature flavor wouldn’t get diluted.
The result is a vegan cookie that tastes just like the traditional recipe. I even tested them on Kevin’s coworkers and they were blown away! That being said, just because the cookie tastes traditional does not mean the dough behaved traditionally!
The dough after hydration is quite crumbly. I tried a number of things to combat this, adding water, changing sugars, and thickening my aquafaba. In the end I went back to original recipe because it looked the best although they all tasted about the same. So know the dough will be crumbly when you roll it into balls. If after hydration it refuses to hold a ball shape, add a little more aquafaba, but it should still be pretty dry. As the dough warms up in your hand, it should come together enough to roll.
Couple more things to note: First, this cookie doesn’t really rise or spread much, so the they’ll come out of the oven in the same shape and size they went in. The second is that the cookies should cool on the pan. When they come out of the oven they will be quite soft but they should look dry on the outside. Unlike cookies with eggs where you can press into the cookie and it will bounce back when it’s done, these won’t behave that way.
Resist the desire to overcook them. Just like chocolate chip cookies, this recipe has better flavor and texture if the center is slightly underdone. If you or someone you bake for is pregnant, elderly or has health issues, you can toast your flour to make sure the cookies are safe to eat. But that would be an overabundance of caution.
Peanut Brittle Popcorn Topping via Vintage Kitty
I love this recipe because it’s a great DIY gift for the holiday season!
Skinny Peanut Butter Energy Bites via Hunger Thirst Play
Get all the flavor and protein of peanut butter without the extra fat!
Peanut Butter Chia Overnight Oats from The Glowing Fridge
Add peanut butter to your morning routine without the extra calories!
Zesty Harissa Hummus via Vintage Kitty
Loads of flavor in this spicy and citrusy homemade hummus. Quite the crowd pleaser!
Easy Chickpea Curry and Spiced Potato Bowl via Vegan Richa
We made this with our leftover chickpeas and it was delish! Really great flavors and super quick to make.
Incredibly Easy Veggie Burger via Kitchen Window Clovers
Skip the frozen patty in favor of this flavorful burger.
Smoky and Spicy Roasted Chickpeas via Foodal
Omnomnom on this healthy snack!
Vegan Peanut Butter Cookies
- 1-1/4 cups flour (5.625 ounces)
- 2 tablespoons peanut powder
- 1/4 teaspoon fine sea salt
- 3/4 teaspoon baking powder
- 3/4 teaspoon baking soda
- 1 cup light brown sugar
- 1/2 cup plus 2 tablespoons creamy peanut butter
- 1/4 cup olive oil (not extra virgin)
- 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
- 3-4 tablespoons aquafaba
- Combine together all of the dry ingredients and whisk them together.
- In a large mixing bowl or stand mixer, combine the sugar and peanut butter and beat until smooth.
- Whisk in olive oil, vanilla extract and three tablespoons of the aquafaba.
- Fold in the flour mixture and mix until all the flour is incorporated.
- Wrap the dough in plastic wrap and let it rest in the refrigerator at least 6 hours or up to 24 hours.
- After the dough has rested, pull it out to warm up a little while your oven is heating to 350F.
- Line two cookie sheets with parchments paper.
- Roll the dough into quarter sized balls and press hashmarks into the top with a fork.
- Bake for 10 minutes.
- Let the cookies cool on the baking sheets.
- Store cookies in an airtight container (if you can keep from eating them all immediately!)
- Resting the dough helps the flour absorb the wet ingredients and enhance the flavor.
- The first two batches I used 3 tablespoons of aquafaba. The third batch was too crumbly to roll so I added an extra tablespoon of aquafaba.
- The dough will feel really oily and be a bit crumbly when you roll it. Although the dough behaves very differently from traditional cookie dough, it bakes beautifully.
- If your fork sticks to your dough when you press it down, dip your fork in peanut powder before making your hashmarks.
- If you're using natural peanut butter (that's what I used) make sure to really stir it good before measuring.
You might also like:
Indian Inspired Buddha Bowls
This Indian Inspired Buddha Bowl is not only vegan and gluten free, but also loaded with fresh veggies.
Vegan Thai Green Curry
Finally, a Vegan Thai Green Curry from scratch that takes only an hour to make! Hello meatless Monday!
Nutty Pear Crumble
This delicious, tart-inspired dessert features a vegan cashew custard with a gluten-free cookie crumb bottom.